: Public Note
Created: |
09/01/2011 01:24:22 |
Modified: |
09/01/2011 01:56:02 |
|
Project: |
|
Author: |
T. Kostic |
Version: |
1.0 |
Phase: |
1.0 |
Status: |
Proposed |
Complexity: |
Easy |
Difficulty: |
|
Priority: |
|
Multiplicity: |
|
Advanced: |
|
UUID: |
{929CA3FF-63E4-422f-9634-389DB2F676A0} |
Appears In: |
13-Limit, Measurement, etc. |
[tk, 2011-01-09]<br/><ul>
<li><font color="#ff0000">Mkt_MeasurementValueQuality: This shadow class is superfluous, the subclasses can inherit directly from MeasurementValueQuality. - </font><font color="#008040"><b>Removed Mkt_MeasurementValueQuality.</b></font></li><li>DiscreteMeasurementValueQuality: If the meaning of attribute 'manualReplaceIndicator' is that the status indication is not tele-metered but manually entered, then it is the synonyme for inherited attribute 'source' with value 'SUBSTITUTED' and should be removed. - <font color="#008040"><b>Will consider</b></font></li><li>Mkt_AnalogLimit: Could attribute 'limitType' be replaced with association to OperationalLimits? If yes, enum AnalogLimitType should be removed. Otherwise, that enum should have literals as strings (and not numbers 1-12). If the numbers are required, they should be put as initial values of literals. In CIM, we still do not use that, but we're likely to start to (for the needs of metering enumerations), so we should follow the same approach. - <font color="#008040"><b>Replaced numerals with string enum values. Will consider limit use change.</b></font></li><li><font color="#ff0000">Mkt_AnalogLimit: Attribute 'exceededLimit' sound useful in general. Propose to WG13 to move it into Limit class. - </font><font color="#008040"><b>Will consider</b></font></li><li><font color="#ff0000">Mkt_AnalogLimitSet: What is 'ratingSet'? Sounds like some implementation detail and should not be part of std CIM. If so, the shadow class Mkt_AnalogLimitSet can be removed. - </font><font color="#008040"><b>Class and attribute remain</b></font></li><li>Mkt_Measurement: It should subtype Analog (instead of Measurement) and be renamed to Mkt_Analog. - <font color="#008040"><b>Will consider (internal review)</b></font></li><li>ViolationLimit: Shouldn't it subtype AnalogLimit instead of just Limit (to respect the full classification of Limit subtypes)?</li></ul>
<br/><br/>